Seventeen-year-old A.J. McCreary is facing all kinds of problems: taking a picture for the cover of the Valentine edition of the school paper; being dateless for the upcoming King of Hearts Dance; and fighting with her dad about her desire to become a photographer. The worst thing for A.J., though, is her many unfortunate dating decisions, and now she is enamored with Peter Terris, who not only is a star athlete and beyond gorgeous, but also deeply involved with the beautiful Julia Hart. When Jonathan, a cupid, visits A.J., offering help in one area of her life, she chooses romance, much against his advice, and orders him to shoot an arrow into Peter’s heart, thus making him love her. A.J. quickly learns that the Peter isn’t the man she imagined he would be, so she desperately cries out for Jonathan, hoping he will reappear and undo the spell that has made her life miserable.